Skip to content

According to the most recent large-scale study, in 2022, only 33% of trans people had the name they wanted on all their IDs, and only 19% said that all their IDs listed the gender they wanted[i]. This means that many trans/nonbinary people have identification documents with either the wrong name/gender on them or they have documents that do not match each other. For example, someone may have an updated driver’s license, but not an updated passport or birth certificate. Someone may have updated their name legally but not filed that change everywhere that has their name listed.

Understanding barriers to having matching ID can help agencies to develop policies that better serve trans survivors.

Reasons why someone might not have ID that matches their current identity

  1. They haven’t updated it yet: Even if someone wants to have ID that matches their current gender identity/name, they may not have gone through the legal steps required. This process can take months or years. The individual may have plans to update their ID but have not done so. They may also be waiting on something before making changes – such as being sure about a name, waiting until they change employment or file for divorce.
  2. The process to update ID is inaccessible: The process of updating ID depends on the state someone is living in. Updating a birth certificate, for example, may require someone to have gender-affirming surgery, which they may not want or have access to[ii]. Updating ID may have a significant financial burden. Other times, states outlaw the process of updating ID entirely[iii].
  3. There is no option that reflects their identity: For nonbinary people who have a gender identity besides “man” or “woman,” updating ID can be even more complicated. Some states now allow an “X” option instead of “M” or “F,” but this is not the case everywhere or for every form of ID[iv]. Even where people can get an “X” option, they may not want to do so, because they do not want a mismatch between the ID that has that and the ID that doesn’t. They may also worry that the “X” indicator would out them as transgender/nonbinary. Laws, both state and federal, related to gender markers on identification are changing rapidly. The Movement Advancement Project tracks applicable laws.
  4. They cannot update ID without losing benefits: Some trans or nonbinary people may need to keep an ID that uses a past gender marker or name to maintain insurance coverage or other benefits.
  5. They may not want to. Not every trans individual wants to change their legal documents. Their identity is just as valid and the barriers they face are just as real, whether or not they want to make these changes.

Impact of non-affirming identification

The impacts of not having matching ID can be significant. Trans and nonbinary people may face discrimination for ID discrepancies, be turned away from services, or lose necessary benefits[v].

Whenever possible, advocates and service providers should re-evaluate policies that require matching IDs or require victims to show ID at all. When providing an ID is necessary, consider how staff are trained to respond when someone’s ID does not match their current name/gender identity/appearance to avoid further victimization.

 

[i] James, S. E., Herman, J. L., Durso, L. E., & Heng-Lehtinen, R. (2024, February). Early Insights: A Report of the 2022 U.S. Transgender Survey. Transequality.Org. https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/2022%20USTS%20Early%20Insights%20Report_FINAL.pdf

[ii] ID Documents Center. (2015, February 5). National Center for Transgender Equality. https://transequality.org/documents

[iii] Identity Document Laws and Policies – Movement Advancement Project. (2026, April 10). Movement Advancement Project. https://mapresearch.org/equality-map/identity-document-laws-and-policies/

[iv] Gregory, S. Y. (2024, November 21). How to Get an X Gender Marker on Your Passport and Other Important Government Documents. Them; Them. https://www.them.us/story/how-to-get-x-gender-marker-on-your-passport-birth-certificate-id

[v] Haug, O. (2021, June 16). Over 476,000 Trans Adults Don’t Have an ID That Matches Their Gender. Them; Them. https://www.them.us/story/476000-trans-adults-dont-have-id-matches-gender

 

Back To Top